Back to Results
Prev Next

200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

$7,900,000 - 8 Beds - 5.1 Baths - 4,744 Sqft - 1.81 Acres

Bunny Key, a premiere historic Islamorada oceanfront plantation. It has been over two decades since this property has been available. Known by its provenance that starts as the LaBranche Fishing Camp in 1937, where it is said the owner and author penned many a fishing tale with the ocean as his muse and passion for fly fishing as his motivation. Once you enter the gate you will be entranced by the prettiest beach on the island of Islamorada with an estimated 240 feet lining the Atlantic ocean. The main home and guest wing of 3 bedrooms radiate character at every corner, reminiscent of a time gone by with the inviting Old Florida porch stepping out on to the beach. The Kitchen is lined in custom Pecky Cypress cabinets and stone counters which blends beautifully with the Dade Countypine flooring throughout. Wake up to the fish tailing and gentle waves along the shore with the palms swaying in the breeze. The sunrises are mesmerizing only to be rivaled by the evening sunsets and starry nights. There is a historic 3 bedroom guest home and a 2 bedroom caretakers cottage on the sprawling grounds each with beautiful verandas featuring ocean vistas. Detached garage and outdoor kitchen area can also be found. This site of almost 2 prime acres is extraordinary and irreplaceable, truly meant to be cherished for the next generation of owners.

Essential Information

For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • MLS® # 579361
  • Price $7,900,000
  • Bedrooms 8
  • Bathrooms 5.10
  • Full Baths 5
  • Half Baths 1
  • Square Footage 4,744
  • Acres 1.81
  • Year Built 1937
  • Type Residential
  • Sub-Type Single Family
  • Style Ground Level
  • Status Active

Community Information

For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • Address 200 Atlantic Street
  • Area 23 - Upper Matecumbe
  • Subdivision Misc Upper Matacumbe (82.0)
  • County Monroe
  • State FL
  • Zip Code 33036


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • Amenities Beach
  • Parking Spaces 4
  • View Ocean View, Open Water View
  • Is Waterfront Yes
  • Waterfront Oceanfront, Open Water


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

FKAA, Municipal Sewer, Cistern, Buyer to Verify


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

Carport, Covered Parking, Garage, Open Parking, RV Parking Open, Off Street Parking


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • Heating Ceiling Fans, Central A/C
  • Fireplace Yes

Interior Features

For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

Built-in Cabinets, Storage, Window Treatments, Fireplace(s), Dade County Pine, Walk-in Closet


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

Dishwasher, Oven, Range, Washer, Dryer, Refrigerator, Gas Appliances, Ice Machine


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • Lot Description 1 Less Than 2 Acres
  • Roof Metal Roof
  • Construction Frame

Exterior Features

For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

Sandy Beach, Storage, Fencing, Detached Guest Qtrs, Outdoor Kitchen, Shed


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

French Doors, Glass Doors, Other Windows/Doors

Additional Information

For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • Date Listed March 21st, 2018
  • Days on Market 544
  • Zoning R1 - Residential Single Family
  • HOA Fees 0.00

Listing Details

For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL
  • Agent Joy Martin


For 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL

American Caribbean Real Estate - Islamorada

Similar Listings Properties for Sale Similar to 200 Atlantic Street, ISLAMORADA, FL


75300 Overseas Highway, ISLAMORADA

4 Beds, 5.1 Baths, 4,610 SqFt
''Sea Garden'' is located on an impressive landscaped 1.5 acre bayfront parcel sprinkled with orchids and boasts a highly unique bayside coral reef right behind the docks. This completely solar powered home has been built to last and offers over 120' of deep water dockage with 13k boat lift plus kayak/paddleboard ramp and floating dock. Three car garage with upstairs guest house is an added bonus to this already impeccable estate. Watch the bald
Ocean Sotheby's International Realty


5 Beds, 5 Baths,
This is an incredible real estate land opportunity on the ocean side of Plantation Key known as Plantation Point South. This 9-acre, estate property boasts 750' feet of shoreline bordering a secluded, conservation parkland with a sandy beach. Build your new, custom home high atop terraced land, positioned to take full advantage of the property's spectacular ocean views. The elevation of this building site allows for ground level construction
Ocean Sotheby's International Realty

139 Gimpy Gulch Drive, ISLAMORADA

6 Beds, 7.3 Baths, 6,573 SqFt
Opulent, alluring and meticulously detailed, this Islamorada Estate is where perfection meets the Bay ~ welcome to The Fish Ranch. Located on Plantation Key, The Fish Ranch estate features two (2) single family residences plus a media house, and cabana with outdoor kitchen. World-class designs make this one of the more distinguished estates for the most discriminating buyer. 100' swimming pool with two beach entries, hot tub, 250' of sandy
Coastal Realty of the Florida Keys

The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.